Top Topics


Please join us on these social networks:

Day1 Store

Books, CDs, Videos & more

Visit The Store

The Passionate Jesus

Day1 host Peter Wallace's new book on the emotions of Jesus is, according to Marcus Borg, “An illuminating and powerful personal meditation." Ideal for personal or group study.

Buy Now

The Rev. Anthony Robinson The Rev. Anthony Robinson
The Rev. Anthony Robinson is a minister in the United Church of Christ, author of 12 books, and president of Congregational Leadership Northwest in Seattle, WA.

Member of:

United Church of Christ

Representative of:

Congregational Leadership Northwest, Seattle, WA

Heath Care Reform, the Court and the Church

June 28, 2012

The Supreme Court decision upholding the Affordable Health Care Act was remarkable in a number of ways -- ways that are suggestive for healthy churches. Most everyone was surprised that Chief Justice Roberts joined the majority, and wrote the decision that upheld AHCA, thus steering away from the ideological polarization that has characterized recent court decisions. Here are three aspects of the AHCA process from which churches may learn.

First, our governance system proved capable of taking on a major and complex issue like health care, reaching a decision and having that decision sustained by the courts. You had to wonder, in recent years, if our often grid-locked system could actually work anymore.

For churches the take-away is this: healthy churches are able to face into tough issues, reach a decision and move on. Unhealthy and declining churches often do not seem to have this capacity. Either issues are not faced or they are never resolved by actually making a decision. Such indecisiveness depletes the energy of a congregation.

A second characteristic of the AHCA appears to be that most people like some of it but not all of it. Some dislike "the mandate" but like the provision that allows adult children to remain on their parent's plans to age 26. Nobody got everything they wanted. Welcome to the real world! It's called "compromise." It's called "politics." You don't get everything you want.

And for churches too the capacity to compromise, to accept something less than what you exactly want is important. It's easy -- in politics and even more so in the church -- to treat our position as sacrosanct and to rule out compromise. When that happens churches are paralyzed and often are headed toward a split.

A third aspect of the court's decision, evident in the Chief Justice's rationale, was respect for other branches of government. The court was reluctant to overturn a major act of the legislative branch unless it clearly was in violation of the Constitution. The Court, that is, respected the turf and purview of the Congress, and minded its own boundaries.

In churches various parts of our governance systems sometimes don't get this. A group or board that has the responsibility for an area and a decision, will find other groups or individuals undoing or undermining their work. Minding boundaries is not just about sexual behavior, its also about governance. When congregations disregard roles and responsibilites and fail to mind boundaries the result is a confused and dispirited congregation.

The capacity to face and issue and resolve it with a decision, the ability to compromise and not get everything we want, and respect for different branches of government and their roles -- all are aspects of the Court's remarkable decision on the AHCA that have interesting and important implications for congregations and their health!



Printer print
Comment comments

Topic Tags

No current tags

Previous Article By This Author

No Previous Article By This Author

Previous Key Voice Article

Bread and Hunger Games

Next Article By This Author

Douthat, Bass and Liberal Christianity

Next Key Voice Article

What Does the Bible Say about Money?

The sermon content on this website is copyright © by the respective authors. For information on reprinting or excerpting sermon materials from this site, please contact us.

Add A Day1 Member Comment

Day1 Member comments have been temporarily disabled.

If you would like to comment, please use our Disqus below: