Bishop Will Willimon: Advice for New Pastors 3

This past year Allan Hugh Cole, professor at Austin Presbyterian Seminary, has edited a book for new pastors, From Midterms to Ministry (Eerdmans).  I was asked to write a chapter in the volume, recounting my own journey from seminary to the parish, drawing out any implications that my experience had for new pastors.

This month, thousands of new pastors will emerge from seminary, a few of them coming to join the ranks of the North Alabama Conference.  I therefore offer these thoughts in the next few weeks, hoping that they will be helpful to those of us who are new in the pastoral ministry and those who are not.

Here is the rest of my list of unsolicited advice for those moving from seminary to parish:

Be open to the possibility that the matters that were focused upon in the course of the seminary curriculum, the questions raised and the arguments engaged, might be a distraction from the true, historic mission and purpose of the church and its ministry.

 

On the other hand, be open to the possibility that the church has a tendency to bed down with mediocrity, to accept the mere status quo as the norm, and to let itself off the theological hook too easily.  One reason why the church needs theology explored and taught in its seminaries is that theology (at its best) keeps making Christian discipleship as hard as it ought to be.  Theology keeps guard over the church’s peculiar speech and the church’s distinctive mission.  Something there is within any accommodated, compromised church (and aren’t they all, in one way or another?) that needs to reassure itself, “All that academic, intellectual, theological stuff is bunk and is irrelevant to the way the church really is.”  The way the church “really is” is faithless, mistaken, cowardly, and compromised.  It’s sad that it is up to seminaries to offer some of the most trenc hant and interesting critiques of the church.  Criticism of the church ought to be part of the ongoing mission of a faithful church that takes Jesus more seriously and itself a little less so.  I pray that your theological education rendered you permanently uneasy with the church.  Promise me that you will, throughout your ministry, never be happy with the church.

 

I pray that you studied hard in seminary, read widely, thought deeply because you are going to need all of that if you are going to stay long as a leader of the church.  Your life would be infinitely easier and less complicated if God had called you to be an accountant or a seminary professor.  Most of the stuff that you read in seminary will only prepare you really to grow and to develop after you leave seminary.  Think of your tough transition into the parish as the beginning, not the end, of your adventure into real growth as a minister.  Theology tends to be wasted on the young.  It’s only when you run into a complete dead end in the parish, when you are aging and tired and fed up with the people of God (and maybe even God too) that you need to know where to go to have a good conversation with some saint in order to make it through the night.   Believe it or not, it’s much easier to beg in in the ministry, even considering the tough transition between seminary and the parish, than it is to continue in ministry.  A winning smile, a pleasing personality, a winsome way with people, none of these are enough to keep you working with Jesus, preaching the Word, nurturing the flock, looking for the lost.  Only God can do that and a major way God does that is through the prayerful, intense reading, study and reflection that you can only begin in three or four years of seminary.

 

Try not to listen to your parishioners when they attempt to use you to weasel out of the claims of Christ.  Much of the criticism that you will receive, many of their negative comments about your work, are just their attempt to excuse themselves from discipleship.  “When you are older, you will understand,” they told me as a young pastor.  “You have still got all that theological stuff in you from seminary. Eventually, you’ll learn,” said older, cynical pastors.  Now it’s, “Because you are a bishop, you don’t really understand that I can’t….”  God has called you to preach and to live the gospel before them and they will use any means to avoid it.  Be suspicious when people encourage you to see the transition from seminary to the parish as mainly a time finally to settle in and make peace with the “real world.”  Jesus Christ is our definition of what’s real and there is much that passes for “the way things are” in the average church that makes Jesus want to grab a whip in hand and clean house.  

 

The next few years could be among the most important in your ministry, including the years that you spent in seminary, because they are the years in which you will form your habits that will make your ministry.  That’s one reason why I think the Lutherans are wise to require an internship year in a parish, before seminary graduation, for their pastors and why I think that a great way to begin is to begin your ministry is as someone’s associate in a team ministry in a larger church.  In a small, rural church, alone, with total responsibility in your shoulders, in the weekly treadmill of sermons and pastoral care, if you are not careful there is too little time to read and reflect, too little time to prepare your first sermons, so you develop bad habits of flying by the seat of your pants, taking short cuts, and borrowing from others what ought to be developed in the workshop of your own soul.  Ministry has a wa y of coming at you, of jerking you around from here to there, so you need to take charge of your time, prioritize your work, and be sure that you don’t neglect the absolute essentials while you are doing the merely important.  If you don’t define your ministry on the basis of your theological commitments, the parish has a way of defining your ministry on the basis of their selfish preoccupations and that is why so many clergy are so harried and tired today.  Mind your habits.

--Will Willimon

[Taken with permission from "A Message from Bishop Will Willimon" to the North Alabama Conference of the United Methodist Church, May 18, 2009]